Askey is better than Hepner and Wilcox. Not just by NCAA tourney results, but also by regular season results.
Askey: 25-7 (R12). Wins over Revano (21 seed), Chittum (14 seed), L. Lamer (29 seed), and B. Lee (11 seed).
Wilcox: 22-12 (R24). Wins over Brady (18 seed @ #165), Mauller (17 seed) and Stampoulos (33 seed)
Hepner: 13-7 (DNQ). Win over C. Moore (28 seed @ #165)
Gallagher has better results than I thought. But still comparative resume to Askey because of Askey's R12 finish.
Gallagher: 16-5 (DNQ). Wins over Chumbley (25 seed), Kellar (AA - 6th), Downey (5 seed).
Hard to look at these resumes and say Askey wouldn't be able to take 1 out of 2 spots.