Starocci had a great year and is really impressive, but his quality of competition this year was not as good as what Parris faced.
Parris beat (by NCAA seeds and scanning through trackwrestling brackets) the No. 2, No. 3 (3x), No. 4 (2x), No. 7, No. 9 (2x), No. 11 (2x), No. 17 (2x), No. 18, No. 20, No. 23 (2x), No. 29, No. 31, and No. 32.
Nine of his matches this year were against top-10 NCAA seeds.
Twenty matches were against NCAA Qualifiers.
He beat five of the seven other placers at his weight a combined 10 times.
Starocci, by comparison, be the No. 2 (2x), No. 4, No. 6, No. 8 (2x), No. 11, No. 12, No. 17 (2x), No. 19, No. 20, No. 30, No. 31, No. 33 (2x)
Six matches against top-10 NCAA seeds
16 matches against NCAA qualifiers
He won five matches against the seven other placers.
Also, the sportsmanship is not a push for the DJ Washington match alone. Parris clears there.
Heart is pretty subjective, but Starocci definitely didn't be Kemerer this year, if that's what you're implying.
The only true edge Carter has is past NCAA credentials, if you ignore the Junior World title Parris won.
I'd hear an argument for Starocci to win the Hodge, but I think it should go to Parris.
If you go down the list:
1. push, both unbeaten
2. Parris pinned 11 guys this year, Starocci pinned five. This one isn't close.
3. Assuming your percentages are correct, Starocci has the edge, but...Parris wrestled nine more matches against better opponents and have more than double the falls. This is a push, honestly.
4. Starocci has better NCAA finishes.
5. Parris.
6. Parris
7. This is a useless, subjective criteria. Parris got healthy and mauled his opponents in the NCAA Tournament. Call this a push.