I hear what you are saying then. I am saying you cannot give 141lb Dake credit for what happened later in his career.
141lb Dake grew so much physically, technically, and mentally by the time he was at 165lbs. To say the 165lb version is the 141lb GOAT is preposterous.
If this was March 30th, 2010 and you made your list and you included 141lb Dake the entire board is laughing you out the door and I am telling you that you are two days early, bud.
An example: I believe the 2020 version of Spencer Lee is the best 125lber we have ever seen. I would also make a case that the 2021 pre-injury might be there, too, but I won't because I am taking the entire season in to account.