Okay, so his wins against whom?
He beat Lewis. We have established that. Lewis is one tier higher, which is fine for the way my tiers are stacked.
Who else has he beat that would warrant he move higher? Has he beaten anyone in Tier 3 or 4?
No. You can try to discredit last seasons postseason all you want, but those were peak performance results - supposedly. They still matter for the sake of tiers, at this point. Especially since Labs hasn't shown anything to prove he has separated himself. That 5-3 O'Reilly(~tier 5?) win doesn't help prove that.