Since I'm a Penn State fan I only know PSU examples.
To me, recruited over means there is a wrestler already on the roster who is either the starter or expected to be the starter when the coach brings in a new wrestler via recruiting or transfer who supplants the first wrestler. This only really applies if the first wrestler is a top level recruit.
Examples:
1. David Taylor over Bubba Jenkins
2. Greg Kervliet over Seth Nevills
3. Max Dean over Michael Beard
4. Michael Beard over Gavin Hoffman
Not an example: Anthony Cassar over Nick Nevills, since Cassar was always on the Penn State roster but just couldn't crack the starting lineup.
What are some examples from other teams?