I am not stating my preferences as to crunchy or creamy on a public forum, however I think the greater challenge can be in finding good taste without a lot of extra sugar and separation of oil, and a good texture etc
I have to tip the cap to Wegmans organic - both crunchy and creamy (but not saying which is my favorite) as they execute very well. Most of my dogs like it too!
Of course, I am probably in no posiiton to lecture Mr. P B on such things and everyone has their favorites.