I might be wrong about the following as I don't follow HS outside of Florida and Michigan too much and neither went to a Michigan school.
I do believe they were competitive when Feldman went to 285 from 220 and Carroll was there. The gap widened when Feldman established himself as THE #1 285lber and Carroll dropped to 220. Carroll then took some losses to other legit guys (maybe just one guy, but still).
Carroll is now going back up for college. Feldman has had a year advantage in the college room and a year advantage in the growing department (out not up, obvi). I am interested at seeing how this weekend plays out, as I believe Catka is entered? A great barometer if they meet in the best of three.
Until he puts results out there against current D1 gents I am not assuming he is an upgrade on Doucet. Ornerydwarf wasn't BONAFIDE' in my opinion. He placed 8th in a watered down 2021 field. Otherwise he didn't do shit.