Maybe because Kerkvliet destroyed him at the all star and voters took note. Criteria isn't that big a deal when you hear some guys talk. They are going to vote the way they want to vote.
Carr and O'Toole are building a great rivalry BECAUSE THEY DON'T DUCK. It is the fact they always step up that is making this great.
Wrestlers who lose in the all star should be taken off the list. Can't unring a bell.