Pendleton is a great coach, but he doesn't have 4 gold medals. That's a huge recruiting edge with HS kids, they want to wrestle for a guy who has won it all on the highest level. I'm not sure how many HS kids even know who Chris Pendleton is, his wrestling career ended in 2005 and I bet none of the current D1 wrestlers ever saw Chris wrestle a match (except maybe on youtube)! David Taylor, on the other hand, is like an icon to HS wrestlers. Taylor is recent enough that some of the HS kids today may have watched him winning his last NCAA title when they were little shits in elementary school. Plus David has had a great Sr level career and they are certainly aware of that. No offense, but comparing Chris Pendleton to DT, wrestling wise, is like comparing prime Cindy Williams to prime Barbara Eden. Yeah, Cindy was pretty cute, but Barbara is one of the all time greatest pieces of....well, you get the point. Try not to think too much about me comparing wrestling resumes to women.
By the way the guy below was married to Barbara Eden, so don't lose hope ugly dudes.