I'd consider it mostly a wash this year. I will say that the coverage, announcing, and view-ability goes hands down to the Scuffle. I disliked the Salute having 4 mats going for the semi-finals for the men and that they didn't have any commentating on the streams for any of the rounds, including the finals. I attended the Scuffle and do believe they put on a superior experience for the attending and online viewing fans.